Best payroll services for small businesses with contractors
Payroll software for a small business with contractors must handle employees, contractors and ordinary invoices without treating them as the same type of worker. Australian teams may also need PAYG tax withholding, superannuation, GST records, Single Touch Payroll reporting and award-compliant rostering in one place.
The right service depends on your accounting platform, workforce size and how contractors invoice. A cafe in Melbourne may need shift-based payroll, while a Sydney consultancy might mainly need reliable contractor payments and clear expense records. The strongest options combine accurate calculations with useful automation and transparent costs.
Why contractor payroll differs in Australia
A worker’s contract label does not determine their employment status. A genuine independent contractor generally controls how the work is performed and invoices for outcomes, while an employee usually works under direction and receives PAYG withholding, superannuation and payslips. Misclassification can expose a business to back pay, penalties and outstanding superannuation liabilities.
Contractors are normally paid through invoices rather than a standard employee payroll run. Their invoice may include GST if they are GST registered, and payment usually comes from the business bank account without tax or super being deducted. Some platforms offer dedicated contractor payments, while others require contractors to be recorded as bills or expenses.
Australian reporting also affects the choice. Employee payroll commonly includes PAYG, superannuation, payslips and Single Touch Payroll reporting, while contractor payments appear in the business’s accounting and BAS records. The Australian financial year runs from 1 July to 30 June, making timely exports and reconciliations important at year-end.
QuickBooks Online Payroll for accounting-first teams
QuickBooks Online Payroll is a practical choice for businesses that already use QuickBooks or want payroll, contractors and bookkeeping in one accounting system. Eligible QuickBooks plans connect employee payments with invoices, bills, bank feeds and reporting, reducing the manual transfers that create reconciliation errors.
Contractor handling depends on the current product plan and payment method. Some businesses can record contractor bills and schedule payments, while others use a contractor payment feature within Payroll. The trial should therefore include a genuine contractor invoice rather than relying on a generic employee demonstration.
Pricing generally combines a QuickBooks subscription with payroll fees based on employees or payroll activity. Australian businesses should check whether quoted prices include GST and whether additional charges apply for payment processing, reports or multiple entities. For wider bookkeeping comparisons, this overview of tax preparation software can help identify tools for organised year-end records.
Xero paired with a payroll specialist
For Australian businesses committed to Xero, the most useful shortlist may include Xero plus a compatible payroll provider rather than payroll as a separate accounting workflow. Payroll partners have included services such as Deputy, Employment Hero, PayHQ and Roubler, although availability and feature support should be confirmed for the specific plan.
This arrangement suits consultancies, agencies and professional firms with frequent contractor invoices. Employee payroll information can flow into Xero, while contractor bills remain visible as liabilities until payment. Automatic reconciliation helps connect payroll-funded accounts, tax liabilities and superannuation with the general ledger.
A contractor-heavy company may need less software than a full-service payroll suite. If there are no Australian employees, Xero’s bills, approvals and scheduled payments might handle contractor invoices more efficiently. A mixed workforce needs both functions to share contacts, payment details and reporting without duplicate entries.
Deputy for rostering and time tracking
Deputy stands out for businesses where hours and schedules drive labour costs. Its time-and-attendance tools, rostering and payroll connections are useful for cafes, restaurants, cleaning businesses and retail operations. A cafe in Melbourne or a restaurant group in Sydney can build shifts, capture attendance and compare recorded hours with payroll.
Award-related features can help managers create compliant rosters and identify labour-cost risks. They do not transfer the employer’s responsibility to the software, so managers still need to check classifications, overtime, breaks and penalty rates for each location. Payroll may also sit in a paid Deputy add-on rather than the base subscription.
Contractors require particular attention because time-tracking does not always mean payroll. Deputy may record work completed for a contractor while the payment itself remains an invoice or bill processed elsewhere. Confirm that the chosen plan handles contractor approvals, payment records and exports in the way your business expects.
Employment Hero and MYOB for scaling teams
Employment Hero is suited to growing businesses that need payroll alongside rostering, leave management, onboarding, recruitment and employee records. Its broader workforce modules can save time for a company expanding beyond a small founder-led team, while payroll automation handles recurring PAYG, superannuation, payslips and reporting.
MYOB Payroll is another contender for businesses using MYOB accounting software. It supports employee payroll administration and payslip delivery, with the precise contractor-payment process depending on the selected plan. This makes it worth testing alongside Employment Hero rather than assuming either option fits every MYOB customer.
Both platforms provide tools that assist with award interpretation and workforce compliance, but neither removes the need for sound contracts and accurate job data. Businesses should also check workers compensation insurance requirements, including cover in NSW and Victorian obligations, alongside payroll fees and employee support.
Practical shortlists for common Australian businesses
The strongest shortlist depends more on operating model than on company size. Compare the services using your own workflow, currencies, reporting requirements and contractor mix rather than relying on a generic feature count.
The first shortlist matches common business models with suitable platforms:
- Consultancies and agencies: Xero with a compatible payroll connector keeps contractor bills, approvals and project costs closely connected.
- Cafés and hospitality groups: Deputy offers strong shift-based rostering, attendance tracking and award-oriented controls.
- Accounting-led microbusinesses: QuickBooks Online Payroll suits teams wanting employee payroll and bookkeeping in the same ecosystem.
- Multi-site service companies: Employment Hero brings together payroll, workforce records and operational management for distributed teams.
A second shortlist identifies the issues to test during a paid trial:
- Total cost: combine the base subscription, per-person charges, payroll runs, payment fees and extra modules in Australian dollars.
- Contractor handling: confirm invoices, GST details, approval rules, payment methods and accounting treatment are supported.
- Compliance coverage: check PAYG calculations, superannuation, Single Touch Payroll, BAS support and modern award functions.
- Data portability: verify that reports, leave balances, contractor records and employee details can be exported without penalties.
Even a feature-rich platform can perform poorly if its contractor workflow forces employees and invoices into separate systems. The trial should include one mixed pay run, one contractor invoice and one month-end reconciliation. That exposes hidden setup charges, confusing payment categories and reporting gaps before a long-term commitment.
Choose a provider that supports compliant growth
The best payroll service for small businesses with contractors is the one that matches the workforce structure and accounting habits. QuickBooks leads for accounting consolidation, Xero offers a strong partner ecosystem, Deputy focuses on workforce scheduling, and Employment Hero or MYOB suit businesses seeking broader administration.
Ask each finalist to process a realistic sample and explain every fee, tax calculation, superannuation contribution and contractor payment. Check local support availability, security controls, onboarding time and how quickly the provider answers payroll-specific questions in Australian business hours.
Start with a shortlisted trial, involve the person responsible for bookkeeping, and compare the completed workflow rather than the sales demonstration. Select the provider that produces accurate records, supports compliant work and can continue serving the business as employees and contractors are added.